Get an Estimate

Blog, Planning

How do I compare heat pump estimates?

Put the estimates side by side and compare the work each one includes, not just the total at the bottom.

Last Updated:

The short answer

Compare the work, not the total. Line up the model numbers and size, the reason for that size, the duct and electrical work, the permit, removal and disposal, and the startup checks. A lower total can leave one of those out. Anything missing from the paper is work you may pay for later.

Two printed heat pump estimates on a kitchen table in a Bakersfield ranch house, a pen and a highlighter beside them, afternoon light from a west window.

Why do my estimates look so different?

Most of the gap comes from the work around the equipment, not the box itself. Before you pick the lowest number, check that every estimate is pricing the same job.

In Bakersfield the job is rarely just a box swap. Each of these changes the work, and each one either shows up on the paper or it does not:

  • Ducts in a hot attic.
  • An old breaker.
  • An outdoor unit jammed against a west wall.

When we quote a heat pump replacement, we visit the house first and write down what we checked. That gives you a fixed list to hold the other estimates against. Here is the order we use.

Which equipment is each estimate actually pricing?

Model numbers, not brand names

A brand name tells you very little. The model numbers for the outdoor unit and the indoor coil or air handler tell you the size, the type of compressor and whether the two parts belong together. Our estimate lists both. If one sheet says “3-ton heat pump system” with no model numbers, you cannot compare it to anything.

A matched indoor and outdoor pair

A heat pump is rated as a matched set. A new outdoor unit hung on an old coil may run, but it is not the system on the spec sheet. Read our guide on matching the indoor and outdoor equipment for why this matters in a long cooling season.

Single-stage or variable-speed

Two estimates can look close in price and be different classes of equipment. A variable-speed heat pump runs longer at lower output. A single-stage unit runs at full output or not at all. Neither is wrong, but you need to know which one each sheet is pricing.

Does each estimate say why it chose that size?

Ours does. We size from the house, not from the old unit, and our estimate states the size and the reason.

We run a load calculation using the industry method known as ACCA Manual J, with your square footage, windows, insulation, orientation and attic. If another sheet simply repeats the tonnage on the old nameplate, ask why. Our guide to how heat pump sizing works explains what goes into the number.

What work sits around the equipment?

This is where totals drift apart. Put a tick next to each line that every estimate covers.

Line to find What it covers What a blank line can mean
Duct check and repair Leaks, crushed runs, return air size Nobody tested the ducts
Electrical Breaker size, wire, disconnect, panel room A second bill from an electrician
Permit Filing, inspection Work done without a permit
Removal and disposal Old unit, coil or furnace, refrigerant recovery Old equipment left on your side yard
Pad, line set, condensate Base for the unit, refrigerant lines, drain Old lines reused without a check
Thermostat Heat pump compatible control and setup Auxiliary heat runs more than it needs to
Startup checks Charge, airflow, temperatures, defrost No record that the system runs as designed

In Rosedale we replaced a 3-ton system in a 1,700 sq ft single-story ranch, along with one crushed supply run to the west bedrooms. That run was its own line on the estimate. The job came to $11,000 and one day on site. Without that line, the west bedrooms would have stayed hot.

How do I handle the permit line?

We check your address before the permit is filed, because the address decides which office reviews and inspects the work. The permit is a line on our written estimate.

If another estimate has no permit line, ask whether it is included. Our page on heat pump permits in Bakersfield and Kern County covers how the address decides who inspects the work.

Where do rebates and options go?

On their own lines. We never count a rebate in your price until it is approved, and we price optional upgrades separately so the base job stays easy to compare.

A rebate depends on your address, your utility, the equipment and the program’s funding. Optional upgrades include things like a better thermostat or extra duct sealing.

What does a fair total look like?

Veranda’s typical range for a like-for-like ducted heat pump replacement is $6,500 to $15,500. The written estimate after the site visit is the real number for your house.

Where your house lands depends on what the visit shows: duct repairs, a new circuit, a harder placement or a larger system all move it. Our replacement cost guide walks through each one, and our cost estimator gives you a starting point before we visit.

What can I do with my estimates today?

Lay the sheets side by side and mark them up. Four quick passes show where they differ:

  • Highlight the model numbers on each sheet and check the indoor and outdoor parts are a matched pair.
  • Circle the size and look for a written reason next to it.
  • Tick the duct, electrical, permit, disposal and startup lines.
  • Write a question next to every blank.

Then call us at (661) 269-7726 or request an estimate and we will go through any of it with you. If you are still deciding whether to replace at all, start with repair or replace a heat pump.

Questions about this post

Why do two heat pump estimates for the same house list different tonnage?

Usually because one was sized from a load calculation and the other was matched to the old unit or the square footage. We size from the house itself, so our estimate says what size we chose and why. If the sizes differ, ask each estimate to explain its number.

Is a heat pump estimate with no duct work listed cheaper for the same job?

Not always. A blank duct line can mean the ducts tested fine, or it can mean nobody looked. On our estimates the duct check result is written down, and any repair is its own line, so you can see which case applies.

What does a removal and disposal line on a heat pump estimate cover?

Taking out the old outdoor unit, coil or furnace, recovering the refrigerant, and hauling the equipment away. On our estimates it is a separate line so you can see it is included and compare it directly against another estimate.

Want this answered for your house?

We look at the equipment, the ducts and the panel, and put the options and a price in writing.

Keep reading

Get an estimate for your house

Step 1 of 2

The house and the work